Movie Review: The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey (pt. I)

I’ve always been a big fan of J.R.R. Tolkien. I read “The Hobbit” and “The Lord of the Rings” for the first time when I was like nine or something. They were the first real series I ever read. I enjoyed Peter Jackson’s movie adaptations of “The Lord of the Rings” considerably, so I had high hopes for “The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey.” I saw I the other night with a friend of mine. Overall, we both liked it. We weren’t blown away by it, but we did like it.


For those that don’t know, “The Hobbit” tells the story of the hobbit, Bilbo Baggins (Frodo’s uncle), and the great adventure of his youth when he accompanied the band of thirteen dwarves led by Thorin Oakenshield on their quest to reclaim the Lonely Mountain from the dragon, Smaug. Smaug is, of course, a classic western-style dragon. Big, mean, and nasty. He’s got claws and teeth and breathes fire. He even speaks. Once, years ago, the Lonely Mountain was the seat of a great dwarven kingdom filled with wealth immeasurable. It is this wealth that attracted the dragon, and in one terrible day of fire and death, the dwarves were driven out and Smaug took over management of the mountain. 🙂


Thorin, who is heir to the throne under the mountain, is set on getting his kingdom and his treasure back. So, he sets out with twelve other dwarves and a solitary hobbit “burglar” to help him. Of course, in the beginning adventure, Bilbo has very few skills beyond maybe cooking and is an all-around sorry excuse for a burglar. Oh, there is also the great wizard Gandalf the Grey who kind-of comes-and-goes as he pleases—but he’s there to help the dwarves out here and there.


The company of dwarves plus a hobbit plus a wizard set out from Hobbiton in the Shire. They encounter numerous nifty creatures along their journey. First, there are trolls. Then, there are orcs and wargs (I think this first encounter with orcs and wargs is an addition by Peter Jackson), elves, stone giants, goblins, and a goblin king. Oh, and we can’t forget the legendary Gollum from whom Bilbo acquires the One Ring of Power. Overall, the Hobbit is an excellent modern fairy tale.


Like in “The Lord of the Rings,” Peter Jackson does do a remarkably good adaption of “The Hobbit.” Still, I have a few complaints. One, I did not like Radagast the Brown very much. He came across as too odd and jerky; his sleigh pulled by over-sized rabbits struck me as simply silly. It might entertain a five year-old, but I would hardly recommend Peter Jackson’s version of “The Hobbit” to the age group. Second, perhaps in some misguided attempt to appeal to the five-year-old age group, there were a couple ironic asides that I could have done without. Still, overall the movie was good. I liked the Pale Orc and his White Warg—I thought they were clever touches. I liked the scenes from Dol Guldur with the Necromancer and his minions even though Radagast was annoying. I’m still withholding judgment on the dragon. We get a few glimpses of him—not in his entirety, but a snatch here or there. I’m not quite sure if I like what I’ve seen yet or not.


Anyway, I’ll give the film four stars out of five.

7 thoughts on “Movie Review: The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey (pt. I)

  1. Steve

    I haven’t seen this yet but I object vehemently to the addition of scenes for what primarily (cynically?) are commercial purposes: If there isn’t three movies worth of story don’t make three movies. And I am beyond tired of movies which go out of their way to cater to toddlers… Nonetheless I may (or may not) still watch this out of a youthful love of the original (praying the whole time the memory won’t be tarnished!).

    1. atoasttodragons

      My thought was that LOTR was definitely NOT a kid’s movie. I was expecting the Hobbit to come across the same way. But there were a couple of things in it that just seemed too kiddie, like Jackson wasn’t sure if he wanted to make a kid’s movie or not. I know the book was more of a kid’s book, but still.

      1. Steve

        Certain scenes in LOTR scared te crap out of me! Definitely not for kids. It seems to me there are enough kid’s movies out there – not everything has to be made childish. But again, I haven’t seen The Hobbit yet. Maybe I’ll like it…

  2. debyfredericks

    I’m with Steve. I probably won’t see the movie, notwithstanding the dragon. If you have to add so much material (yeah, it’s supposed to be archival material, don’t care) you really just need to write your own original story. Isn’t Jackson married to a screen writer? Fran somebody… He could have commissioned her to write a screenplay about necromancers, if that’s what he wanted so badly.


Leave a Reply